FREE U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $75 ❤
0 Cart
Added to Cart
    You have items in your cart
    You have 1 item in your cart
    Total
    Check Out Continue Shopping

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 61 reviews
    89%
    (54)
    10%
    (6)
    2%
    (1)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    A
    Anonymous
    Lovely!

    I loved it! The scent was very nice and not too strong (I can be sensitive to harsh scents) and it was very fun to mess with! It was fun to pull and stretch, as there was very minimal snapping, and it kept its shape very well. It was very nice!

    J
    Jill Rose
    Sugar Cookie delivers on scent and texture!

    LOVE this slime!! As a returning customer, I must say that Slime Fantasies slimes are ALWAYS 5-star quality :)

    L
    Lillian
    Amazing!

    This slime was so creamy, dreamy, and spreadable! It smelt just like Sugar Cookies (freshly baked!) and the sprinkles were the PERFECT addition. Would HIGHLY recommend!!

    H
    Hannah Jones
    sugar cookie

    i love my slime it’s super soft and it smells great!

    C
    Cassie
    Soft and perfect!

    This butter slime is so soft and has such a nice cookie vanilla smell! It's not too strong, and the glitter and sprinkles don't overpower the slime itself. Absolutely perfect!

    T
    Tennille Casillas

    I love the texture and the sprinkles, there is a bit of fall out and it does shrink a little after a few days of play but I still enjoy iy. The scent didnt smell like sugar cookie to me but still nice

    S
    Sierra
    not overpowering

    I've tried slimes from Kawaii slime company, slime Obsidian, dope slimes, OG slime, and several etsy sellers. These are hands down the best slimes. They have a texture that never sticks to you hands, they have minimal shrinkage and do not harden.

    I liken this one to cupcake but it is better because the round sprinkles do not fall out everywhere and the smell is more subtle. the cupcake can be too much after a while but this one is perfect. more buttery texture compared to cupcake which has a cloud to it.

    A
    Ally
    So soft!!

    The slime is very soft and good!

    C
    Christina Griffin
    AMAZING

    I bought this for my daughter. Now everyone in the house wants one :)

    S
    Samantha Gilbert
    Sugar Cookie

    My favorite slime out of all that i bought!